Business

Big Problems with Laws Regulating Business

Big Problems with Laws Regulating Business

November 30
00:00 -0001

Big Problems with Laws Regulating Business

The problem with implementing laws in order to enforce business ethics is that, unfortunately, laws are retrospective. No law will ever combat a crime that isn’t somehow provided for within that law, and similarly, most crimes are not crimes until they have been identified and a law has been implemented against them.
This is the nature of our common law system, in which a great deal of the law that might matter in business ethics cases actually comes from other such cases and establishes important precedent beforehand. A full overview of the common law that affects cases of ethical behavior in business, then, is very difficult, not the least which because it is quite variable and ill-defined beyond that specific case.
Yet another problem standing in the way of laws that would regulate business ethics cases is that such laws actually lead to a negative depiction of the relationship between law and ethics. Common law might dictate certain key precedents when dealing with business ethics cases, but if business ethics relies only upon compliance with common law combined with actual legal statutes, then the ethics are diminished in force.
In other words, if, in business ethics cases, a given business can be shown to have acted in accordance with the law, then under the comprehension of business ethics that defines it as simply following the laws, that business would have acted ethically regardless of what it actually did.
Because common law is based on precedent, it is entirely possible that a given company could determine a way to perform an otherwise entirely unethical action that is perfectly legal within the scope of the law up to that point. After all, if there is no law prohibiting the act, then the act is not illegal, and if business ethics cases focus on ethics as synonymous with obeying the law, then businesses will not be restrained from performing any given act until such a time as that act is prohibited under either common law or official statute.
As a prime example of this problem regarding the relationship between laws and business ethics, take the famed Ford Pinto cases, which involved the Ford Pinto model of car. Ford, in designing the car, came up with a different model design that would likely result in 180 fewer deaths per year according to Ford’s statistics. This alternate design would also have cost an additional $11 per car. Ford, following the law as set up in common law and prior business ethics cases, used a cost benefit analysis in order to determine whether or not they should implement the different design.
This cost benefit analysis was originally designed to be used with regard to a single accident, whereas in this case Ford was using it to cover the entire line of a given product. But it was legal for Ford to do so, as established in precedent. Ford decided not to implement the safer design because it determined that the costs would be greater to implement the other design than it would be to simply allow 180 customers to die per year.
Inarguably, Ford’s decision was unethical, but it did conform with the common law of the time. As a result, if business ethics cases focus primarily on obeisance to the law, then Ford could not be held accountable for its actions. The law could then be changed, but Ford’s own particular instance of unethical behavior would still stand unpunished.
In order for business ethics cases to be effective at moving towards stronger ethical practices, ethics need to be detached from mere obeisance to the law. No amount of business law will ever be enough to ensure ethical practice in business.
Share

About Author

admin

admin

Related Articles

Business News

Google and IBM Discover Massive New Market Opportunity Mamadou Ndiaye grew up in the impoverished nation of Senegal.
Deep Fried: Burger King Twitter Hacked Deep Fried: Burger King Twitter Hacked Just two weeks after traces of horse meat were found in beef patties at a Burger King supply center in Europe, the fast-food chain’s Twitter was hacked.
Berkshire and 3G Capital Purchase Heinz for $23 Billion Berkshire and 3G Capital Purchase Heinz for $23 Billion Buffet, the CEO of Berkshire Hathaway, announced on Thursday that it plans to purchase the food giant for roughly $23 billion, adding Heinz Ketchup to the conglomerate’s stable of respected brands.
Martha Stewart Back in Court Again Martha Stewart Back in Court Again On Tuesday, the home decorating and banking icon appeared before the New York State Supreme court to defend her choice to sign a contract with J.
Young Adults are Too Broke for Loans Young Adults are Too Broke for Loans Young adults are facing less debt than they were 10 years ago, but that is not necessarily a good thing.
Lawsuit Alleges Budweiser Waters-down its Beer Lawsuit Alleges Budweiser Waters-down its Beer Beer drinkers across the United States have accused Anheuser-Busch of watering down its Michelob, Budweiser and other beer brands, in class-action suits that seek tens of millions in damages.
CNBC to Purchase “Nightly Business Report” CNBC to Purchase “Nightly Business Report” “Nightly Business Report,” the inventive public television series that has come into financial troubles in recent years, attracted a new deep-pocketed commercial owner, the 24-hour news and business cable channel CNBC, an element of Comcast’s NBC Universal.
Google Launches Touchscreen Chromebook Google Launches Touchscreen Chromebook Google on Thursday introduced a high-resolution Chrome OS portable computer equipped with a touchscreen.
Investigations Continue Into Plywood from China Investigations Continue Into Plywood from China On November 9, 2012, the International Trade Commission (USITC) announced that continuing investigations allege that hardwood plywood from China was subsidized and sold for less than fair value in the United States.
Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission Sign Memorandum with Two Indian Authorities Department of Justice and Federal Trade Commission Sign Memorandum with Two Indian Authorities On September 27, 2012, the US Department of Justice and the Federal Trade Commission signed a memorandum of understanding with the Government of India Ministry of Corporate Affairs as well as the Competition Commission of India.
Another Taiwan Manufacturer Pleads Guilty to Price-Fixing Another Taiwan Manufacturer Pleads Guilty to Price-Fixing On September 25, 2012, the Department of Justice announced that the vice chairman of a Taiwan aftermarket auto lights manufacturer pled guilty to an international price-fixing conspiracy.
CME Group Software Engineer Guilty of Stealing Trade Secrets CME Group Software Engineer Guilty of Stealing Trade Secrets On September 19, 2012, the US Attorney’s Office in the Northern District of Illinois reported that Chunlai Yang pleaded guilty of two counts theft of trade secrets after working for CME Group for 11 years.
Economists Predict Meager Growth in 2011 Economists Predict Meager Growth in 2011 A number of businesses and financial analysts predict that the United States’ economy will grow only slightly in 2011, a bleaker forecast that was offered in July, when most entity’s called for a stronger improvement.
End of the Road for Steuben Crystal End of the Road for Steuben Crystal Steuben Glass, a name that once evoked images of prestige and sophistication, appears to be vanishing for good.

Guide To: Business Lawyers

Guide to Finding Business Lawyer Guide to Finding Business Lawyer How do I find a Business Lawyer?Business lawyers are essential for commercial enterprises to ensure that they remain knowledgeable of the laws regulating their business and protecting their assets from liability.
Guide to Finding Tax Lawyer Guide to Finding Tax Lawyer How do I find a Tax Lawyer?Tax lawyers specialize in helping clients who need guidance in navigating the complex tax codes of the United States and local state taxes.
Guide to Finding Bankruptcy Lawyer Guide to Finding Bankruptcy Lawyer Questions to ask, Fees, Preparing for appointment.